Dissertation journal articles

There are several steps writers seeking to prepare their dissertation or thesis for publication can take beforehand:. Adapting a dissertation or thesis into a journal article is covered in Section The original research reported in a dissertation and thesis can then be reformatted for journal submission following one of two general strategies: the multiple-paper strategy or the conversion strategy. This involves structuring the dissertation or thesis used to fulfill the requirements for a degree as a series of shorter papers that are already formatted for journal submission or close to it. These papers are usually each the length of a journal article, conceptually similar, and come from the same overarching project—but can stand alone as independent research reports.

A second strategy is to reformat and convert a dissertation or thesis into a journal article after completing your dissertation or thesis defense to fit the scope and style of a journal article. This often requires adjustments to the following elements:. Deciding to Submit a Dissertation or Thesis for Publication When deciding whether to publish the work in your dissertation or thesis, first consider whether the findings tell a compelling story or answer important questions.

Adapting a Dissertation or Thesis for Publication Once a decision is made to convert your dissertation or thesis into a manuscript for submission to a journal, you will want to focus attention on adapting it for publication. There are several steps writers seeking to prepare their dissertation or thesis for publication can take beforehand: Look at articles in the field and in relevant journals to see what structure and focus are appropriate for their work and how they are formatted.

Request and consider the input of advisors, colleagues, or other coauthors who contributed to the research on which the dissertation or thesis is based. Review an article submitted to a journal alongside their advisor with permission from the journal editor or serve as a reviewer for a student competition to gain firsthand insight into how authors are evaluated when undergoing peer review. Conversion Strategy A second strategy is to reformat and convert a dissertation or thesis into a journal article after completing your dissertation or thesis defense to fit the scope and style of a journal article.

Eight top tips to help you turn your PhD thesis into an article

This often requires adjustments to the following elements: Length: Brevity is an important consideration for a manuscript to be considered for journal publication, particularly in the introduction and Discussion sections. Making a dissertation or thesis publication-ready often involves reducing a document of over pages to one third of its original length. If the work examined several research questions, you may consider separating distinct research questions into individual papers; narrow the focus to a specific topic for each paper.

Abstract: The abstract may need to be condensed to meet the length requirements of the journal.

Journal abstract requirements are usually more limited than college or university requirements. For instance, most APA journals limit the abstract length to words. Introduction section: One of the major challenges in reformatting a dissertation or thesis is paring down its comprehensive literature review to a more succinct one suitable for the introduction of a journal article.

Limit the introductory text to material relating to the immediate context of your research questions and hypotheses. End with a clear description of the questions, aims, or hypotheses that informed your research. Method section: Provide enough information to allow readers to understand how the data were collected and evaluated. The first step in selecting a journal where to submit a manuscript is to consider as many fields of study that might pertain to the planned article. For example, a study on Hispanic patients' compliance with doctors' health recommendations might appeal to the readership of journals with a focus on Hispanic populations and issues, journals with a focus on ethnic and language issues for minority populations, public health journals, health policy journals, journals that deal with ethics, or interpreting and translation, or many other healthcare journals including those geared toward practitioners vs.

Strive to create a list of at least five fields of study that overlap with the dissertation or proposed manuscript's content. Do not worry at this point about the main focus of the manuscript and what field of study that it pertains to. Think broadly at this stage; the journal choices can be narrowed at a later time. For example, my field of study happens to be deaf individuals.

There are many times when something I've written could be of interest to a wider or altogether different audience, even though the content of the article happens to be about deaf people. I can always inform my colleagues in the small deafness field to an article that I have published elsewhere. Informing and motivating a broader audience to find something that I have published in an obscure deaf journal is a lot more difficult.

If making a list of fields of study that overlap with the manuscript content seems difficult, the following exercise might help. Pretend that the dissertation or other work product is going to be made into a newspaper story from the s.

  • literature review for the energy demand research project.
  • Adapting a Dissertation or Thesis Into a Journal Article?
  • the old man and the sea essay outline.
  • What are "scholarly sources?" - Dissertation Editor.
  • Thesis and Dissertation!
  • Eight top tips to help you turn your PhD thesis into an article!
  • Useful Links;

Nearly 1, Lost Steamship Carpathia Rescues Hundreds Roles of Saved and Missing Stirring Eyewitness Accounts. Printing numerous headlines stimulated a wider variety of people to buy the newspaper. Similarly, the headlines that could be written about the dissertation or other work product will suggest different types of readers, and therefore journals, to consider.

This should not take long at all. The reference list from the dissertation or thesis may provide clues to journals that publish in these topic areas. Now, there should be a list of around 10 or 15 journals under consideration. Next, again using advice from librarians, on-line resources, or colleagues, list some of the major characteristics of each of these journals.

Characteristics to consider include: intended audience e. Competitiveness is a very important characteristic in making the decision about which journal to target the manuscript.

  • dream of my life essay!
  • mba plan of study essay!
  • graph interpretation essay.

Librarians or journal editors themselves will readily provide you with these competitiveness indicators. For example, the American Psychological Association APA publishes an annual report containing most of this information regarding the journals it publishes, usually in the August archival issue of the American Psychologist. Data from 28 APA journals were presented in the most recent report 1. None of the above journal characteristics are necessarily good or bad. Their importance is in matching the manuscript optimally to the goals and characteristics of the journal.

Many times, I write manuscripts that would not be appropriate for a highly competitive or widely distributed journal. For example, I once gave a speech that I thought was unique and deserved to be in print. I chose a journal with limited circulation, one that was not very competitive but was happy to receive my submission. Now, I frequently distribute copies of that article and it is another peer-reviewed publication on my resume. Now it is time to narrow down the list of potential journals by comparing their characteristics to those of the dissertation or other existing or hypothesized work product.

This is a multi-step process. To begin, consider the ultimate goal in publishing the manuscript. Is it to influence clinicians' behavior? Then, focus on journals that are geared toward clinicians and be prepared to write a short article, as clinicians are busy people.

Related Reading

Is it to inform a particular group e. Then, focus on journals that are commonly read by those audiences. Is the content applicable to a wide audience? Then focus on journals that are generalized, not specialty journals, and journals that have wide circulation. However, these are often among the most competitive journals. Alternately, a very specialized topic may demand a specialized journal.


Journal Article vs Thesis

Is the goal to introduce an audience to a topic that they would not normally think or care about? Then, consider publishing in a journal geared toward audiences who are interested in the general topic of the manuscript e. Is the goal simply to get something into print that is worthwhile but not particularly sophisticated or influential, rather than never publish it at all? That is a fine goal; a less competitive journal may be a wise choice in that situation. Compare the list of journal characteristics to these and other such questions, noting in each case whether a given journal on the list seems to be advantageous, disadvantageous, or neutral.

This process should narrow down the list of journals by at least half, leaving you with no more than 5 — 7 journals still under consideration. Some journals publish this in each issue, others only once per year. Most journals will have this document on their website. Study that page for additional information that can further narrow the list of journal options. The instructions page may contain lists of topics that are welcomed or discouraged, information on page limits, and descriptions of the different types of manuscripts it welcomes e.

Some journals have several sections, each one devoted to a different type of manuscript. Do not limit the conceptualization of journal-worthy publications to full-fledged research studies. There are many types of articles that journals welcome.

Certainly, there is a style that will match any fresh idea or experience one would like to impart, no matter how much that idea or experience differs from a conventional research study. After considering the above factors as they relate to the dissertation or intended manuscript, narrow down the journal options to three or fewer. If the final choice is not obvious by now, it may be helpful to contact the journal editor to discuss the nature of the intended submission and whether or not the editor thinks it is appropriate for the publication.

Editors are proud of their journals and, in some sense, are like talent scouts in that they are always on the lookout for appropriate, quality submissions, especially from new authors. Most will give generously of their time and advise or guide in this matter. Send the editor a brief e-mail describing the essential features of the proposed manuscript i. This is a more neutral approach than attaching a copy of the manuscript and asking or implying that the editor should review the entire article.

This brief e-mail is simply seeking a quick opinion on whether a manuscript such as the one planned or actually completed would be welcome for review. If that particular journal does not seem appropriate, the editor may advise on how to alter the manuscript so that it would be more appropriate or give advice on alternative publication outlets that would be more appropriate. After a final decision has been made on the most appropriate journal for submission, ensure that the manuscript conforms to the characteristics, style, and preferences of the chosen journal.

Also, follow exactly the instructions given to potential authors. The following method has proven valuable in helping writers pare down their dissertations to manageable size, yielding a manuscript that reflects the most essential elements of the dissertation but also complements the characteristics, style, and preferences of the journal that was chosen as the preferred publication outlet.

Tip 1. Identify the appropriate target journal

As will be described below, after the bullet point list is created, a number of strategies are used to distinguish essential bullet points from unessential ones based upon the views, motives, and knowledge base of the intended readership of the chosen journal for submission, and not from the author's viewpoint. Finally, the remaining bullet points are organized according to a functional outline of the manuscript.

The manuscript first begins to take shape through compiling a list of several dozen or so bullet points, each one identifying a fact, issue, finding, or other detail that must be written about. These bullet points are chosen and organized in a fashion that will allow the manuscript to flow smoothly and logically for the intended reader.